Point #16
The following are NOT opinions, but actual verifiable facts. Research any of it if you have doubts or just want to expand your knowledge.
16) the anti-vaccine movement isn't new, and wasn't born from Jenny McCarthy. It began soon after vaccines were introduced and outbreaks in recently vaccinated populations raised questions as to the safety and effectiveness of vaccines.
More nested claims:
- The anti-vaccine movement isn't new;
- Jenny McCarthy did not create the anti-vaccine movement
- The anti-vaccine movement began soon after vaccines were introduced
- Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in recently vaccinated populations raised questions about vaccine safety and efficacy
Discussion:
#1 "The anti-vaccine movement isn't new" True-ish. There's not a monolithic anti-vaccine movement with organizational links to previous organizations and leagues, but rejection of vaccines have existed since the practice began. See the excellent article at The History of Vaccines: Anti-vaccination Movements in History and Today OBJECTIVE FACT
#2 "Jenny McCarthy did not create the anti-vaccine movement". No, it far-predated McCarthy's 2007 Oprah appearance, as the timeline at The History of Vaccines showed. (McCarthy failed to monetize her earlier belief that her son was not autistic, but an "Indigo Child".) And McCarthy abandoned her anti-vaccine crusade in 2015 or thereabouts. OBJECTIVE FACT
#3 The anti-vaccine movement began soon after vaccines were introduced. True. What is surprising is how resistant the various movements and leagues have been to evidence intended to calm their unfounded fears. OBJECTIVE FACT
"Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in recently vaccinated populations raised questions about vaccine safety and efficacy" This is just ahistorical posturing, or the author riding her hobby-horse that vaccines are unsafe and ineffective. Some early opposition was to the legal mandates for vaccination, and other opposition was rooted in health beliefs such as "vaccines weaken the immune system" THE AUTHOR'S OPINION.<
VERDICT: MIXED, A combination of OBJECTIVE FACT and THE AUTHOR'S OPINION.
Here is the list of claims, with links to the discussion of each claim:
- Bonus: Claim that "I'm doing the research that your pediatrician NEVER had to do."
- #1 Combined doses of Vaccines have NEVER been tested for safety.
- #2 Vaccine manufacturers have been granted legal immunity from being sued when their products inflict damage.
- #3 DNA from aborted fetuses is in vaccines.
- #4 the CDC has been caught destroying and hiding evidence
- #5 outbreaks occur in populations that are up to 90-99% vaccinated -- herd immunity a myth
- #6 More people die from the MMR vaccine itself than die of the measles.
- #7 Peanut allergies were almost unheard of prior to the use of peanut oil in vaccines.
- #8 Multiple independent studies have shown vaccinated children are more likely to have asthma.
- #9 Information on vaccines is hidden from parents.
- #10 Vaccine package inserts prove the dangers of vaccines.
- #11 Doctors are bribed to vaccinate
- #12 Vaccine manufacturers and the CDC are only self-regulated
- #13 Doctors are ill-informed about vaccines
- #14 Vaccines cause SIDS&
- #15 Diseases have been renamed after the introduction of a vaccine.
- #16 The anti-vaccine movement isn't new
- #17 All live virus vaccines shed and cause diseases
- #18 Combining acetaminophen and vaccines is dangerous.
- Bonus: MTHFR gene variants and vaccination
Comments