Ty Bollinger released an anti-vaccine video series, The Truth About Vaccines, (TTAV) in April of 2017. (Bollinger is best known for patient-killing cancer quackery). As a part of the "educational" outreach, Bollinger released a renumbered, pirated copy of Ginger Taylor's list, calling it "130 Studies Linking Vaccines to Neurological and Autoimmune Disorders Common to Autism."
This is the URL I used to access the list:
(click on all images to see full-size)
Bollinger is again hawking the video series:
So I went through the TTAV list systematically. Whoever made the list used some sort of numbering application that was inconsistent. Whenever there was a number that did not refer to a specific paper, I entered "missing". There are no missing papers -- they correspond exactly to Taylor's list (with one exception -- Taylor had the retracted Mawson paper as her #2 in 2017. See Chad Hayes MD on the problems with the paper). There are just numbers with no corresponding papers.
Here's a visual example of the "missing" phenomenon
Taylor numbers 1 to 30 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation.html. NONE of the papers establish that vaccines have anything to do with autism, or "neurological and autoimmune disorders common to autism".
See also 124 (now 144) papers that DO NOT prove vaccines cause autism (by a trauma surgeon) and Vaccines and autism: A thorough review of the evidence
The Bollinger list:
- 1. Verstraeten (Taylor #1 of the 131 iteration)
- 2. Gallagher & Goodman (Taylor #3 of the of the 131 iteration)
- 3. Missing
- 4. Missing
- 5. Missing
- 6. Missing
- 7. Missing
- 8. Missing
- 9. Missing
- 10. Missing
- 11. Missing
- 12. Branch DR (Taylor # 4 of the 131 iteration)
- 13. Missing
- 14. Missing
- 15. Ekstrand 2010 (Taylor # 5 of the 131 iteration)
- 16. Missing
- 17. Missing
- 18. Rubenstein 2015 (Taylor # 6 of the 131 iteration)
- 19. Haley 2005 (Taylor # 7 of the 131 iteration)
- 20. Yassa 2014 (Taylor # 8 of the 131 iteration)
- 21. Tomljenovic L, Shaw CA 2011 (Taylor # 9 of the 131 iteration)
- 22. Missing
- 23. Missing
- 24. Shaw CA, Li Y, Tomljenovic L. 2013 (Taylor # 10 of the 131 iteration)
- 25. Missing
- 26. Missing
- 27. Shaw, Seneff et al. 2014 (Taylor # 11 of the 131 iteration)
- 28. Missing
- 29. Missing
- 30. Missing
- 31. Missing
- 32. Nevison, (Taylor # 12 of the 131 iteration)
- 33. Blaurock-Busch, 2012 (Taylor # 13 of the 131 iteration)
- 34. Yasuda 2013 (Taylor # 14 of the 131 iteration)
- 35. Singh 2003 (Taylor # 15 of the 131 iteration)
- 36. Molina 2005 (Taylor # 16 of the 131 iteration)
- 37. Deisher 2014 (Taylor # 17 of the 131 iteration)
- 38. Delong (Taylor # 18 of the 131 iteration) -- this one has the same typo about DeLong's name
- 39. Missing
- 40. Missing
- 41. Olczak 2009 (Taylor # 19 of the 131 iteration)
- 42. Missing
- 43. Missing
- 44. Missing
- 45. Missing
- 46. Chen, 2013 (Taylor # 20 of the 131 iteration)
- 47. Missing
- 48. Missing
- 49. Li, 2014 (Taylor # 21 of the 131 iteration)
- 50. Olczak 2010 (Taylor # 22 of the 131 iteration)
- 51. Olczak 2011 (Taylor # 23 of the 131 iteration)
- 52. Missing
- 53. Missing
- 54. Sharpe 2013 (Taylor # 24 of the 131 iteration)
- 55. Sharpe 2012 (Taylor # 25 of the 131 iteration)
- 56. Missing
- 57. Missing
- 58. Missing
- 59. Zhang 2014 (Taylor # 26 of the 131 iteration)
- 60. Missing
- 61. Missing
- 62. Carvalho 2009 (Taylor # 27 of the 131 iteration)
- 63. Missing
- 64. Missing
- 65. Carvalho 2011 (Taylor # 28 of the 131 iteration)
- 66. Singh 1998 (Taylor # 29 of the 131 iteration)
- 67. James 2004 (Taylor # 30 of the 131 iteration)
Taylor numbers 1 to 30 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation.html
Taylor numbers 31 to 60 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-31-60.html
- 68. Missing
- 69. Missing
- 70. Khaled 2016 (Taylor # 31 of the 131 iteration)
- 71. Nataf 2006 (Taylor # 32 of the 131 iteration)
- 72. Missing
- 73. Missing
- 74. Austin 2008 (Taylor # 33 of the 131 iteration)
- 75. Youn 2010 (Taylor # 34 of the 131 iteration)
- 76. Goth 2006 (Taylor # 35 of the 131 iteration)
- 77. Breece 2013 (Taylor # 36 of the 131 iteration)
- 78. Burbacher 2005 (Taylor # 37 of the 131 iteration)
- 79. Missing
- 80. Missing
- 81. Missing
- 82. Missing
- 83. Missing
- 84. Missing
- 85. Missing
- 86. Rooney 2014 (Taylor # 38 of the 131 iteration)
- 87. Missing
- 88. Rice 1989 (Taylor # 39 of the 131 iteration)
- 89. Akinrinade 2014 (Taylor # 40 of the 131 iteration)
- 90. Charleston 1994 (Taylor # 41 of the 131 iteration)
- 91. Vargas 2005 (Taylor # 42 of the 131 iteration)
- 92. Missing
- 93. Missing
- 94. Missing
- 95. Missing
- 96. Morgan 2010 (Taylor # 43 of the 131 iteration)
- 97. Missing
- 98. Missing
- 99. Missing
- 100. Gupta 2014 (Taylor # 44 of the 131 iteration)
- 101. Missing
- 102. Missing
- 103. Missing
- 104. Lukiw 2005 (Taylor # 45 of the 131 iteration)
- 105. Missing
- 106. Missing
- 107. Missing
- 108. Missing
- 109. Missing
- 110. Missing
- 111. Young, 2011 (Taylor # 46 of the 131 iteration)
- 112. Missing
- 113. Missing
- 114. Missing
- 115. Naik, 2011 (Taylor # 47 of the 131 iteration)
- 116. Herbert 2005 (Taylor # 48 of the 131 iteration)
- 117. Waly 2004 (Taylor # 49 of the 131 iteration)
- 118. Werner 2005 (Taylor # 50 of the 131 iteration)
- 119. Desoto 2007 (Taylor # 51 of the 131 iteration)
- 120. Seneff 2012 (Taylor # 52 of the 131 iteration)
- 121. Ghanizadeh 2013 (Taylor # 53 of the 131 iteration)
- 122. Poling 2006 (Taylor # 54 of the 131 iteration)
- 123. Sajdel-Sulkowska 2008 (Taylor # 55 of the 131 iteration)
- 124. Missing
- 125. Missing
- 126. Herbert 2005 (Taylor # 56 of the 131 iteration)
- 127. Kern 2006 9Taylor # 57 of the 131 iteration)
- 128. Chauhan 2006 9Taylor # 58 of the 131 iteration)
- 129. James 2005 (Taylor # 59 of the 131 iteration)
- 130. Missing
- 131. Missing
- 132. Ercal 2001 (Taylor # 60 of the 131 iteration)
Taylor numbers 31 to 60 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-31-60.html
Taylor numbers 61 to 90 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-61-90.html
- 133. Petrik 2007 (Taylor # 61 of the 131 iteration)
- 134. Missing
- 135. Gorrindo 2013 (Taylor # 62 of the 131 iteration)
- 136. Holmes 2003 (Taylor # 63 of the 131 iteration)
- 137. Geier 2007 (Taylor # 64 of the 131 iteration)
- 138. Blaxill 2003 (Taylor # 65 of the 131 iteration)
- 139. Gargus 2009 (Taylor # 66 of the 131 iteration)
- 140. Anderson 2008 (Taylor # 67 of the 131 iteration)
- 141. Missing
- 142. Neustadt 2007 (Taylor # 68 of the 131 iteration)
- 143. Rossignol 2008 (Taylor # 68 of the 131 iteration)
- 144. Palmer 2008 (Taylor # 70 of the 131 iteration)
- 145. Oliveira 2007 (Taylor # 71 of the 131 iteration)
- 146. Yel 2005 (Taylor # 72 of the 131 iteration)
- 147. Humphrey 2005 (Taylor # 73 of the 131 iteration)
- 148. Kawashti 2006 (Taylor # 74 of the 131 iteration)
- 149. Hewitson 2008 (Taylor # 75 of the 131 iteration)
- 150. Young 2008 (Taylor # 76 of the 131 iteration)
- 151. Schulz 2000 (Taylor # 77 of the 131 iteration)
- 152. Gallagher 2008 (Taylor # 78 of the 131 iteration)
- 153. Minami 2009 (Taylor # 79 of the 131 iteration)
- 154. Kempuraj 2010 (Taylor # 80 of the 131 iteration)
- 155. Missing
- 156. Missing
- 157. Missing
- 158. Fiorentino 2016 (Taylor # 81 of the 131 iteration)
- 159. Hewitson 2010 (Taylor # 82 of the 131 iteration)
- 160. Walker 2006 (Taylor # 83 of the 131 iteration)
- 161. Desoto 2010 (Taylor # 84 of the 131 iteration)
- 162. Woods 2010 (Taylor # 85 of the 131 iteration)
- 163. Rossignol 2011 (Taylor # 86 of the 131 iteration)
- 164. Migdal 2010 (Taylor # 87 of the 131 iteration)
- 165. Blaxill 2004 (Taylor # 88 of the 131 iteration)
- 166. Rimland 2002 (Taylor # 89 of the 131 iteration)
- 167. Ratajczak 2011 (Taylor # 90 of the 131 iteration)
Taylor numbers 61 to 90 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-61-90.html
Taylor numbers 91 to 131 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-91-131.html
- 168. Stajich 2000 (Taylor # 91 of the 131 iteration)
- 169. Guy 2015 (Taylor # 92 of the 131 iteration)
- 170. D'Onofrio 2013 (Taylor # 93 of the 131 iteration)
- 171. Shandley 2011 (Taylor # 94 of the 131 iteration)
- 172. Zhang 2012 (Taylor # 95 of the 131 iteration)
- 173. Vestergaard 2004 (Taylor # 96 of the 131 iteration)
- 174. Missing
- 175. Missing
- 176. Feenstra 2014 (Taylor # 97 of the 131 iteration)
- 177. Missing
- 178. Wilson 2011 (Taylor # 98 of the 131 iteration)
- 179. Robertson 2015 (Taylor # 99 of the 131 iteration)
- 180. Duszczyk-Budhathoki 2012 (Taylor # 100 of the 131 iteration)
- 181. Olczak 2010 (Taylor # 101 of the 131 iteration)
- 182. Missing
- 183. Missing
- 184. Holland 2011 (Taylor # 102 of the 131 iteration)
- 185. Dorea 2011 (Taylor # 103 of the 131 iteration)
- 186. Hamza 2012 (Taylor # 104 of the 131 iteration)
- 187. Herdman 2006 (Taylor # 105 of the 131 iteration)
- 188. Sulkowski 2012 (Taylor # 106 of the 131 iteration)
- 189. Hertz-Picciotto 2009 (Taylor # 107 of the 131 iteration)
- 190. Missing
- 191. Missing
- 192. Missing
- 193. Khan 2013 (Taylor # 108 of the 131 iteration)
- 194. Blaxill 2004 (Taylor # 109 of the 131 iteration)
- 195. Windham 2005 (Taylor # 110 of the 131 iteration)
- 196. Palmer 2006 (Taylor # 111 of the 131 iteration)
- 197. Dickerson 2015 (Taylor # 112 of the 131 iteration)
- 190. Christian 2011 (Taylor # 113 of the 131 iteration)
- 199. Brown 2013 (Taylor # 114 of the 131 iteration)
- 200. Ewing (Taylor # 115 of the 131 iteration)
- 201. Sienkiewicz 2012 (Taylor # 116 of the 131 iteration)
- 202. Gesundheit 2013 (Taylor # 117 of the 131 iteration)
- 203. Walker (Taylor # 118 of the 131 iteration)
- 204. Stamova (Taylor # 119 of the 131 iteration)
- 205. Weizman 1982 (Taylor # 120 of the 131 iteration)
- 206. Kawashima 2000 (Taylor # 121 of the 131 iteration)
- 207. Tomljenovic & CA Shaw 2012 (Taylor # 122 of the 131 iteration)
- 208. Shaw 2014 (Taylor # 123 of the 131 iteration)
- 209. Missing
- 210. Missing
- 211. Missing
- 212. Wu 2008 (Taylor # 124 of the 131 iteration)
- 213. King 2013 (Taylor # 125 of the 131 iteration)
- 214. Missing
- 215. Missing
- 216. Missing
- 217. Shaw 2013 (Taylor # 126 of the 131 iteration)
- 218. Li 2014 (Taylor # 127 of the 131 iteration)
- 219. Tsumiyama 2009 (Taylor # 128 of the 131 iteration)
- 220. Missing
- 221. Missing
- 222. Mumper 2013 (Taylor # 129 of the 131 iteration)
- 223. Ewing 2009 ((Taylor # 130 of the 131 iteration, repeat of #115)
- 224. Kanner 1943 ((Taylor # 131 of the 131 iteration)
Taylor numbers 91 to 131 are analyzed in order at this link: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2017/05/are-there-131-papers-that-support-vaccineautism-causation-papers-91-131.html
The pirated Taylor list ends at page 146 of the 156 page PDF. Pages 147 to 158 are W a list of "39 Studies linking thimerosal to autism " -- which I will address in a second post.
I have watched all the episodes of The Truth About Vaccines. I was going to write a series of reviews, but happily for me, Immunization Champion Kathy Hennessey did my work for me, at her excellent blog Vaccines Work. Here are her reviews:
- The Truth about vaccines: who are the experts? https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/19/truth-about-vaccines-who-are-the-experts/
- The Truth about Vaccines Episode 1: Top Ten lies debunked https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/16/the-truth-about-vaccines-episode-1-top-ten-lies-debunked/
- The Truth about vaccines 2, more lies https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/18/the-truth-about-vaccines-2-more-lies/
- The Truth about vaccines 3: MMR, DTaP, and the Greater Good https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/20/the-truth-about-vaccines-3-mmr-dtap-and-the-greater-good/
- The Truth about vaccines 4: influenza, HIB, and pneumococcal vaccines and herd immunity https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/29/the-truth-about-vaccines-4-influenza-hib-and-pneumococcal-vaccines-and-herd-immunity/
- The Truth about vaccines episode 5: HPV, Hep B, SIDS, and Shaken Baby Syndrome https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/03/the-truth-about-vaccines-episode-5-hpv-hep-b-sids-and-shaken-baby-syndrome/
- The Truth about vaccines 6: rotavirus https://vaccinesworkblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/16/the-truth-about-vaccines-6-rotavirus/
Comments