Some parents in New York City felt it was fine to ask their doctor to lie about their childrens' immunization status. The doctor had no problem lying either. Would you trust a pediatrician like that? Would you ask your doctor to lie for you? Under what conditions?
New York Post: Doctor Fesses Up
An Upper West Side pediatrician who conspired with families to get their young kids into school without state-mandated shots has been disciplined in the first case of its kind in New York, The Post has learned.
Dr. Mark Nesselson was fined $10,000 by a state disciplinary panel this month and told he can practice only under supervision. He admitted to state charges of falsifying forms for four children in two families.
The 50-year-old pediatrician told The Post he's done the same for at least a handful of other families over the years.
The cheating was discovered when Nesselson moves to another state, and the parents migrated to a new physician, who did not share Nesselson's views on fraudulent reporting.
Here's what one of the parents had to say"
A Manhattan mother of two for whom Nesselson falsified records said she did not want her kids to have the shot for measles, mumps and rubella - the MMR vaccine - until they were older.
As I understand it, the reason for immunizing infants against the diseases are twofold: the <12 month set tends to have more serious illness if those diseases are contracted, and for reasons of convenience and compliance: the immunizations have to be given on a schedule, and the infant is probably already being seen for well-baby checkups.
The worried mom said since the family never traveled and the diseases were rare in New York, she didn't feel she was putting her kids or others at risk.
"The form was filled out," she said of the falsified record. "We knew what we were doing."
She said her children had the vaccine when they were older - after they entered school.
I'm not a New York state resident, so I don't know what the regulations are. They may apply to pre-school. California allows "personal belief" exemptions from immunization. California does not require either pre-school or kindergarten, but does require students to attend school once they turn six, and requires immunization once enrolled:
The California School Immunization law requires that all children entering school receive proper immunizations to protect them from serious illness and to prevent the spread of communicable diseases: polio, measles, rubella, mumps, hepatitis B, varicella (chickenpox), diphtheria, tetanus, haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib meningitis), and whooping cough.
Although I don't think it is of much benefit to the child, I don't have a quarrel with parents who decide to delay immunization until the child is older than the APA's suggested immunization schedule, or who decide to go the much more expensive route of individual inoculations (ie, inoculating only for mumps, then for measles, then for rubella, for example). I do have a problem with parents sending un-vaccinated kids to school, and lying about it.
Recent Comments